News:

These forums are now archived - New member registrations are closed - Please join the discussion over on our Discord

Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - Veritas

#2
Klaw - watch episode two. Episode 1 is half the pilot. It's ridiculous that they split it; it is much, much stronger with episode 2 alongside it. Episode two adds a lot that was missing from episode one, fixes things that didn't make sense, and just generally adds a sense of connection to the show and material episode one didn't have. If this tanks on CBS because of All Access and being split in the wrong place, I'll be really disappointed in the studio :(.

Here is my spoiler-free review, copied and pasted shamelessly from my post on Reddit:

Quote
VFX: absolutely stunning, almost if not actually movie quality. Character design is great. Ship design is excellent. Space VFX are amazingly good, beautiful on their own much of the time. They clearly put a lot of time and money into this. Note, though, it is JJ Abrams' style more than anything. If you didn't like that, you won't like this. Personally, I enjoy the style, so I thought it was fantastic. I'm also digging the new Klingon designs. 10/10

The writing/characterization is solid, but not perfect. Some significant things to be worked on, but I can't go into details without spoilers. However, in my opinion if you watch both episodes 1 and 2 (and you really should watch both), there's nothing so glaring or unresolved/unfixable that it really detracted from the experience. 8.5/10

The music is good, but nothing new/unexpected. It doesn't reach michael giacchino levels, but it's well-executed. For sound effects, the same rating/statement. It's the sound suite expected from Star Trek, mixed with some modern stuff like the Expanse. 8/10

The acting is a mixed bag. Honestly, this is probably the weakest part of the episodes so far for me; issues with delivery/directing more than capability, I think, but we'll see. Again, can't be too specific without spoilers. Work is needed here. While I agree that the writing is not perfect, I think it'd come across a lot better with better directing and acting. I didn't have issues with pacing/style of direction that other people here did, but I am going to watch again soon and think about these things specifically. The directing is definitely not perfect. 7/10 for both, I'd say.

In terms of streaming experience, while All Access is dumb, and putting the show back 18 minutes online because of football, which is on TV makes absolutely zero sense, for me (streaming on a desktop computer over a decent Internet connection), the streaming worked flawlessly; it was high quality thewhole time with no interruptions or downtime whatsoever. There was no HBO-Go-first-ep-of-game-of-thrones downtime here. I strongly recommend ditching your TV or mobile apps and streaming through a browser for this platform. For me, the streaming was 10/10. For others, I hear it is much worse.

Finally, the most important part - is it Star Trek? YES. IT IS STAR TREK. IT IS ABSOLUTELY STAR TREK. It's modernized to a certain extent and it's more action-oriented than Star Trek usually is, but I think that's because it's a pilot/season-opener, which is similar to what TNG/DS9/VOY all did during all their first episodes. It is absolutely Star Trek, it hits all the right beats and I feel like it means them. 10/10 will space voyage again.

Overall, if this were just any scifi TV show, I'd call it an ~8, 8.5/10. But I love Star Trek, and I want to love this, so it gets a 9/10 for me, with hope for the future.

and here are some musings from me on Trek idealism and what to expect from a new Trek show:

Quote
Guys, we have to talk about this. I realize that everyone has specific ideals about what Star Trek is supposed to be, and that those ideals are important. I promise, I'm right there with you. The trouble is that Discovery, good or bad, is never going to be your platonic ideal of a Star Trek show, because its creators are not you. I think we need to remember a few things:

Every major Trek series since TOS has changed things, sometimes significant things, often for the better.
Every major Trek series since TOS was criticized harshly by at least some contingent of fans at first, regardless of how it ultimately turned out.
Every major Trek series has occasionally (or more than occasionally, looking at you, Voyager) suffered from bad writing, bad acting, bad directing, or all three - including in the pilot episodes.
Everyone has their list of things Star Trek is and should be. Those lists aren't necessarily equal to what Star Trek is.

I believe that at its core, Star Trek is about a theme: idealistic, optimistic science-fiction that keeps the "human" factor in mind, even when dealing with aliens. Star Trek is a show about ideals and values. Those ideals and values can be brought under discussion in a myriad of ways and under a myriad of artistic styles and visions, because at its core, Star Trek is not about whether there's lens flares or not, what the commander's name is, or how many scenes of Klingons talking about destiny and the ancestors there are. Star Trek is about vision, and vision takes time.

Personally, I really enjoyed these first two episodes. I don't think they're perfect - acting and writing need work, directing was sometimes heavy-handed - and yes, they are modern scifi designed for a modern audience (just as TNG was in its time, and ENT in its, as examples). But to me, they have the spark of what Star Trek is and should be about. They're character-driven, they're focused on the meaning behind the actions shown, and they are at the same time about big ideas and cosmic conflicts bigger than any single person - or at least, personally, I can see them getting there if they're not there 100% yet.

Even if I liked it, it can be improved, and I want it to be improved. But at the same time, even if someone didn't like it, I think they are more likely to be rewarded for giving the show time and watching it with an eye towards what works than by throwing their hands up, declaring "it's not Trek!" and storming out. You miss all the shots you don't take.
#3
Just finished episodes 1 and 2. I am extremely pleased so far. Looking forward to hearing what you all think; I might type up my thoughts longform later...
#4
Quote from: Callum603 on August 27, 2017, 06:28:38 PM
I've not received any spam myself.


60-80 a day is rather alarming though.  I will look into this and attempt to filter it out.  The fact it's being flagged as spam is a good sign at least.  It might be worth me moving the full time filtering up my list of things todo as I'll be able to control it much better at that point.


I will look into this tonight and attempt to get it resolved tonight.

Thank you!

Given that others aren't getting much, there's a definite possibility my TLO email ended up on some list somewhere through some indiscretion of mine. I would say, don't feel compelled to spend too much time on it on my behalf if you don't want to.
#5
Hi all,

For those who have @last-outpost.net email address, has anyone noticed a significant uptick in the amount of spam we're getting? I'm seeing about 60-80 spam messages a day to my veritas@last-outpost.net. Most all of them are marked by our servers as spam before they get forwarded on, and either way Gmail (which is where I forward all my email) catches them.

I realize this could actually be my fault (maybe I've signed up for something dodgy in the past with that email), but in case it isn't, wanted to see if anyone else is having the same problem?

Thanks!

Edit: Looking at our DNS setup, my guess is that now that we're hosting our own mail server, we have a different filtering policy than we did when we used Microsoft Domains or whichever service we were using before. Maybe that plays a role?
#6
Good morning, TLO,

This is the last announcement I'll be writing for this group, so I'm glad it's a happy one.

I am pleased to welcome Serris as our new President, as of today, Monday, December 15th. He will assume his responsibilities immediately.

Jenson asked me to write a short statement for the occasion. In accordance with my usual style, I'll keep it blunt - but in a departure, it will also be (relatively) brief:

I never imagined TLO would become as large as it has. None of us did. I'm immensely proud of it. Four and a half years is a long time, no matter what anybody says, and a lot changes, but the one thing that's never changed for me is a sense of wonder at how TLO has grown beyond the four of us who started it.

True, any group as only as good as the people in it - but that's what makes TLO so special. TLO is a great place and it is great because you, each of you, are here. So, be excellent to each other, guys. Don't fight over the little things. Don't forget let the petty stuff make you forget what this place is really for. Remember that behind every computer screen there's an actual human being with thoughts other than your own.

Remember that Star Trek isn't about politics, transporters, phasers or red alerts. It's about discovery. It's about what lies beyond the horizon and the excitement of pushing towards it. That's what TLO did, and that's what matters. I know it can do it even more.

Thank you all very much for your support - in every way - over the past few years, and congrats once again to Serris. I wish him the best of luck.

Veritas
President of The Last Outpost

#7
Hello everyone,

The Last Outpost began as a reference to one of TNG's earliest episodes; it seems only fitting to fast-forward and end with one of the last ones.

When I was elected, I said that if I felt I no longer had time to do my job well, I'd be upfront about it. I also said that I would make arrangements for the future of the group after I left. I informed the Cabient privately a little while ago, and this post is the next step in the process of my departure from leadership in TLO.

Through December, I intend to phase out my involvement in TLO, both as President and as Head of Technical. I will be reducing my activity to essentially zero, in both an official and unofficial capacity, over the period from the end of December through to January 1st, 2015. Naturally, I will be calling the appropriate elections for both positions shortly. As part of making arrangements to secure the long-term stability of the group, I will be working with the Cabinet on other proposals to make certain that all of TLO's financial assets and leadership positions are in good hands. I won't leave anybody in the lurch.

When Jenson, Telex, Klaw and I started this community in July of 2010, we had no conception that it would ever grow to what it is today. TLO has exceeded my wildest expectations, and it has been an absolute pleasure to watch it grow, to work on it and to play with all of you over the past four and a half years. I'm extremely thankful to each and every one of you for being a part of it.

Thank you all. I'll see you out there.

Veritas


#8
Likely, you've incorrectly installed RPGXSE/UE, or you aren't using the version of it that you think you're using. Or, you moved it yourself, or are looking in the wrong place. There's no other reason I can think of for it not to exist.
#9
It's Java, but there's a version of the JRE included with RPGXSE/CE, so that shouldn't prevent it from running. Most likely it's the result of the installer setting registry or cfg paths incorrectly.
#10
What's your com_hunkmegs set to? It looks like RPG-X is trying to allocate more memory than your system has available.
#11
Can you please try again and post a condump following these instructions?
#12
Announcements / Community Day - Winter 2014!
October 08, 2014, 02:21:48 PM
Hello everyone!

TLO is gearing up for its next Community Day, and we want to know what dates work best for all of you.

Check out the poll here and let us know!

http://www.last-outpost.net/forum/index.php?topic=7467.0

Veritas & The Cabinet
#13
I'm not at home; it'd probably take 15-20 minutes, but let's do it later today or tomorrow.
#14
If it's happening that broadly, it's difficult to troubleshoot - I will need to look at what's going on server-side and see what I can do. When you have some time, contact me on Skype; I'd like to take a Wireshark capture of your communications with TLO's servers.
#15
Hi Scott,

The next time this happens, can you please try all the steps in this guide and report back on whether any of them affect anything?

Thanks.